Federal Prosecutor Craig Nolan Joins Sheehey

Craig S. Nolan

Veteran federal and state prosecutor Craig Nolan, 47, of Waterbury, has departed the United States Attorney’s Office for the Burlington law firm Sheehey Furlong & Behm P.C. He joined the firm on April 6, 2015 as a shareholder and director, focusing on complex civil litigation, white collar and serious felony criminal defense, and internal investigations. As part of his litigation practice, Nolan defends health care entities and professionals in malpractice actions and before administrative bodies, and represents businesses in employment actions. Nolan has tried more than twenty-five cases to juries in the federal and state courts of Vermont, and has appeared regularly before the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit and the Vermont Supreme Court.

Nolan stated, “After thirteen years serving the public as a prosecutor, I’m looking forward to new challenges presented by complex litigation in the private sector. I’m honored to join Sheehey – one of the oldest and most respected law firms in the region.” Attorney Eric Miller, a Sheehey shareholder and director, commented, “We’re thrilled to have Craig Nolan become a member of our firm. Craig’s extensive jury trial experience and management of complex investigations and cases as a federal and state prosecutor will greatly benefit our clients.”

Nolan served as Assistant United States Attorney in Burlington and Rutland from January 8, 2007 to April 4, 2015. He held the positions of Rutland Branch Chief and Lead Attorney for the Organized Crime Drug Enforcement Task Force. Nolan investigated and prosecuted financial, narcotics, violent and other crimes. Among his most notable cases was the capital prosecution of Michael Jacques for kidnapping, murder and child pornography production, resulting in imprisonment for life plus seventy years. Nolan also prosecuted Noel Delarosa, of Schenectady, New York, John Brooker, of Rutland, and more than twenty others for the largest powder cocaine conspiracy case in Vermont history. Delarosa and Brooker are serving twenty-five and seventeen years, respectively.

Nolan was State’s Attorney for Washington County from January 2005 to January 2007 and Deputy State’s Attorney for Lamoille County from March 2002 to January 2005. In a 2003 jury trial, Nolan and then-Lamoille County State’s Attorney Joel Page convicted Douglas Provost for his 2001 slaying of four persons in Belvidere. Provost was sentenced to 140 years imprisonment. In 2006, Nolan prosecuted Casey Langlois, of Roxbury, for repeated sexual assaults of a young boy, obtaining a sentence of twenty to sixty years split to serve ten.

Before becoming a prosecutor in 2002, Mr. Nolan litigated commercial disputes and represented physicians, other professionals, and employers as a litigation associate with leading law firms in Burlington, Vermont and Raleigh, North Carolina. Mr. Nolan clerked for the Honorable Fred I. Parker of the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit and the Honorable Terrence W. Boyle of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina.

Nolan graduated with honors from Dartmouth College in 1990. He earned his law degree with honors in 1995 from William & Mary Law School, where he was Editor-in-Chief of the William & Mary Bill of Rights Journal.

Eric Miller Recommended for U.S. Attorney

eric-s-millerSenator Patrick Leahy announced today that he will recommend that President Obama nominate Sheehey attorney Eric Miller to fill the post of United States Attorney for the District of Vermont. Miller has practiced at Sheehey since 1999, and he is consistently recognized by national publications as one of Vermont’s top litigators. Miller has extensive federal court experience in criminal and civil cases, at both the trial and appellate levels. He also represents indigent defendants as a member of the Criminal Justice Act panel for the District of Vermont.

In his announcement, Senator Leahy said “Eric is eminently qualified to be the top Federal law enforcement officer in Vermont, and I am proud to recommend him to serve as Vermont’s next U.S. Attorney.”

Read the Burlington Free Press coverage of Miller’s nomination here.

Ian Carleton Named as Acting Judge in Chittenden and Orleans Counties

CarletonThe firm is pleased to announce that attorney Ian Carleton was recently appointed to the roster of acting judges in Chittenden and Orleans Counties.  As an acting judge, Mr. Carleton will preside over hearings in small claims court, adjudicating the rights of parties who have disputes valued at less than $5,000.  Mr. Carleton is a 1999 graduate of Yale Law School, and regularly represents corporate and individual clients in complex civil and criminal matters.  Mr. Carleton looks forward to serving his community in his new role.

Jim Spink Named to AAA Commercial Arbitration Panel

James W. SpinkSheehey attorney Jim Spink recently completed an intensive two-day training with the American Arbitration Association, becoming Vermont’s newest member of the AAA’s Commercial Arbitration Panel.  Jim regularly mediates and arbitrates civil disputes all over the state.  To schedule a mediation or arbitration, please check Jim’s up-to-date calendar for available dates.

Four Sheehey Attorneys Named 2014 New England Super Lawyers

The firm is pleased to announce that four of its attorneys were named this month by Super Lawyers magazine as among the top New England attorneys in 2014. Attorneys Eric Miller and Jeffrey Behm were recognized as leaders in business litigation. Attorney Michael Furlong was recognized for his work in business and corporate law. Attorney Jim Spink was one of two Vermont lawyers recognized as a leader in alternative dispute resolution. The Super Lawyers list is generated through peer nominations, independent research, and peer evaluations. Each year, only 5% of attorneys are selected as Super Lawyers.

Owen J. McClain Joins Sheehey’s Energy Group

Sheehey Furlong & Behm P.C. is pleased to announce that Owen J. McClain has joined the firm as an associate attorney.  Owen will practice primarily in the firm’s energy group, alongside attorneys Peter Zamore and Debra Bouffard.

Prior to joining the firm, Owen attended Vermont Law School, and clerked for Vermont’s trial courts in Chittenden and Addison counties.  Owen has also worked as a summer associate for the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and as a law clerk for the Executive Office of the Governor.

Carie Tarte to join Vermont Joint Commission on the Future of Legal Services

Carie Tarte, RP®, has been invited to join the Vermont Joint Commission on the Future of Legal Services.  The Commission has been tasked by Chief Justice Paul Reiber of the Vermont Supreme Court to study the question of how to ensure that all Vermonters have access to quality, affordable legal representation.  It was created in a response to a sharp rise in the number of self-represented litigants in Vermont’s courts.

The Commission will consist of four committees.  Ms. Tarte will join the Legal Education and Practice Committee, which will study and develop responses to such questions as:

  • What reforms in the funding and provision of legal education could improve new lawyers’ ability to represent populations that currently lack representation?
  • Are there changes that can be made to Vermont’s unique clerkship program that would attract would-be law students to Vermont and enable new lawyers to provide more economical legal services?
  • What legal education is currently available for paralegals and other legal support personnel?

Ms. Tarte is the President and CLE Committee Chair of the Vermont Paralegal Organization.  Last winter, Ms. Tarte and two other VPO members published an article in the Vermont Bar Journal entitled “Equal Access to Justice: Paralegals and Limited Legal Licensure.”

Ian Carleton Files State and Federal Actions After DNA-Based Exoneration of Man Wrongfully Imprisoned For Nearly 18 Years

Attorney Ian Carleton has filed state and federal civil rights actions on behalf of John Grega, who was wrongfully convicted in 1995 of allegedly murdering his wife and sentenced to a prison term of life without parole. On May 14, 2012, post-conviction DNA testing results (also obtained by Attorney Carleton) revealed the presence of DNA from an unknown male (not Mr. Grega) on never before tested swabs taken during the autopsy of Mrs. Grega. On August 21, 2012, the Vermont Superior Court vacated Mr. Grega’s conviction based on this newly discovered exculpatory evidence. Mr. Grega was released the following day, after 17 years and 8 months in prison. In the wake of these events, Attorney Carleton has filed a variety of state and federal claims on Mr. Grega’s behalf, including claims for wrongful imprisonment, failure to investigate, and malicious prosecution.

Earlier: Ian Carleton Achieves Ground-Breaking Ruling.

Ian Carleton Teaches CLE on Evidence

Earlier this summer Attorney Ian Carleton was invited to serve as a panelist in a CLE offered by the National Business Institute entitled “Applying the Rules of Evidence: What Every Lawyer Needs To Know.”   Mr. Carleton lectured on Ethics, Witnesses, Expert Reports and Scientific Evidence.

Jeffrey Behm and Debra Bouffard Obtain Affirmance of District Court’s Grant of Summary Judgment in the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Vermont v. Milnes

Attorneys Jeffrey Behm and Debra Bouffard have successfully defended a grant of summary judgment obtained on behalf of their client, Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Vermont (“BCBSVT”) in the Second Circuit Court of Appeals.

Earlier in the case, the trial court dismissed a breach of contract claim brought by BCBSVT’s former Chief Executive Officer on grounds of legal impracticability. On appeal, the Second Circuit upheld the trial court’s ruling on the alternative ground that the contract was unenforceable on grounds that it contravened public policy.  Mr. Behm and Ms. Bouffard had argued both grounds in both the United States District Court and in the Court of Appeals.

Jeffrey Behm argued the case before the Court of Appeals.

Earlier: Jeffrey Behm And Debra Bouffard Defend Summary Judgment Order In An Appellee Brief Submitted To The United States Court Of Appeals For The Second Circuit In Blue Cross And Blue Shield Of Vermont v. Milnes (Dkt. No. 13-1748).

Sheehey Furlong & Behm